We built a desktop simulation to help keep the debate honest
The majority of service firms in the New York region, some 61%, now report using AI, the New York Fed found in September. That’s up from just 25% in 2024. The share that reported laying off anyone because of AI? Only 4%. Meanwhile, Microsoft, Barclays and Kroger have joined a lengthening list of companies citing AI as they cut jobs.
It’s early in this supposed economic revolution, but the questions are clear: Is AI failing to deliver automation? Or is it starting to make workers obsolete? The evidence doesn’t tell a coherent, compelling story either way — yet.
Ask a half-dozen experts and you’ll get six different answers, split roughly in two camps. One sees a hollowing-out of white-collar work, a displacement of labor not seen since machines replaced mill workers. The other points to rapid job growth at the very firms spending the most on AI today.





